http://www.PCRules.com/LogitechMomoRacingFFWheelReview.shtml 

 Wednesday, 10-Mar-2010 17:14:15 GMT 

Menu

 

 

 

   
   
     
 
 
 

Home / News

Reviews

Previews

Articles

Forum

 

Cheats

 

Interviews

Screenshots

Downloads

 
Contacts

Links

 
 

Your Account

 Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register.
Log-In / Log-Out

Register

 

Search

 

Network

 

Affiliates

 

 

Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium
without express written permission of the site's owners is prohibited

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Register | Search | | Set as Homepage

Latest Review

Kingston HyperX PC4000 Dual DDR

An extremely high quality product manufactured by Kingston here.

Latest Review

Force Feedback Steering Wheels

Compare the Saitek R440, Logitech Momo Racing and Logitech Formula GP Wheels and see who comes out on top!

Latest Forum Posts

Site Visitors

 -  wouldn't it be great... by Dreetn7
 -  Geforce 6800 (ultra) by Timothy Crittenden
 -  PCRules.com Temperary Closure by Timothy Crittenden
 -  Help by rum744
 -  Half-Life 2 Deathmatch Released by Alex McHardy
 -  Sit Down, Strap In, Scream by Alex McHardy
 -  Digital Jesters at Multiplay UK’s latest party by Timothy Crittenden
 -  Rev Up Your Brain for Trivia Machine! by Timothy Crittenden

 Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register

 

 Who's Online?
5 Guests, 0 Users

Network: XboxRules.com / PCRules.com

UK Based Website covering

World PC News

Staff From:

 


PCRules.com - Logitech Momo Racing FF Wheel Review by Richard Trueman
 

 

Many motor racing fans will be familiar with the Momo name, due to it being a very popular sports car wheel manufacturer. They have collaborated with Logitech to produce this impressive wheel, with their input being most noticeable from the shape and design. On opening the box the first thing you notice is the sturdy, rubber gripped sports car style wheel. This is in stylish black, with red buttons and the yellow Momo logo on the front. There is also a handy red metal strip on the top of the wheel in the middle, which can be useful for judging when the wheel is centred. The wheel has quite a large plastic cased main unit behind it containing the force feedback mechanism. The ergonomics of the wheel are excellent, with the grip being comfortable and easy to hold. That the rubber extends right round the wheel is useful for those who drive with obscure hand positioning.
 

There are two paddles located behind the wheel for gear shifting, as in an F1 car. The paddles are positioned very well, and are within comfortable reach when gripping the wheel. There is also a sequential gear stick, similar to those in a modern rally car, which can be used if preferred. This gear stick can be attached on either side of the wheel to suit your individual taste. The addition of this is a superb design feature. This can be used for added realism, for example I use the paddles when playing F1 games, yet use the gear stick for rally games, as in real life.

 
This wheel uses a superb triple clamping system to attach itself to your desk. This can be seen in the image. The screws for the front two clamps are located underneath a removable covering on the main base, with the third screw being underneath the unit further under your table. The wheel is fairly heavy as well (when compared to the other two), and so this combined with the secure clamping makes the wheel difficult to dislodge. This of course is more necessary when driving rally games, where quick sharp movements are required.
 

 
   

On the front of the wheel are six red buttons, three on each side. Whilst they look very pretty, I would have preferred them to be a bit closer to the rim of the wheel as they can be a bit too far away to reach quickly. This is fine for functions such as traction control override, or view changing. However if you want to use a button for handbrake you may struggle a little. I can normally get round this problem by using the stick for the gears, and then assigning one of the paddles as the handbrake.


I am very impressed by the pedals supplied with this wheel. The whole unit is constructed from durable plastic, and has a superb carpet gripping mechanism on the underside to prevent slippage. The pedals themselves are bottom hinged and look sporty with the holes drilled through them. The weighting of the springs on the pedals is superb. The accelerator is lighter than the brake, as you would expect. The brake pedal actually gets stiffer the further you push it down, which gives a very realistic feel.

Set Up

All of the units plug into each other quickly and easily, with the connection to the computer being via USB. Therefore you have to make sure you have a free connection port for it (obvious really!).


The software included is very quick and easy to set up, with clear instructions for installation. The controller is self calibrating and the intensity of the force feedback effects can be altered. You may want to take a bit of time setting up the effect levels, as each individual will have their own personal preference. The default settings are fine, but it is definitely worth fine tuning it a little yourself. There is also a profiler program included, in which control set ups can be saved for different games. I haven’t really explored this as the controls can be set in all of the games I play. However, it looks fairly easy to use with a simple interface.

 

Performance

When I first used this wheel, I was amazed by how smoothly it steered. The force feedback effects are strong enough for you to feel the road accurately, yet not too strong to rip your arms off. The pedals also have just the right amount of resistance in them, allowing the driver to really feel how much power he is applying, and carefully adjust easily. The only problem I found is that the wheel occasionally loses its centre, but this can easily be fixed by using a program available from http://www.wingmanteam.com/files/Patches/momo_racing_center_fix/ . Below is a game by game analysis of the performance under different driving conditions.
 

     

F1 Challenge


This wheel is frankly superb for this game. The steering is very precise and accurate, and gives the user good control of the car. The steering is slightly heavier than the other wheels I tried (i.e. more like a real car), which suits this game down to the ground. This is because it makes it a lot easier to steer with fluid motions, which is ideal for a track based driving game, where smoothness is the key. If the steering was too light, a lot of jerky movements would be made when trying to steer against the force feedback. The force feedback is excellent for this game, with every turn, rumble strip and spin being felt. It really does give you the feel of driving a real car, and adds immensely to the experience. The pedals also perform excellently, allowing for subtle control of the accelerating and braking.

Colin McRae Rally 04


Although I highly rate this wheel, I have to say that it is not so well suited to rally driving games such as this one. The main reason for this is that it is quite tricky to turn the wheel in the quick, sharp movements needed for rally driving, due to the weight of the steering. Once you get the hang of it the performance is good, but it does take a bit of getting used to. Having the gear stick to use is excellent however, and adds to the authenticity. The sturdy clamping mechanism also means that you can throw this wheel around in full confidence that it will remain firmly attached to your desk. The force feedback lets you feel the road very well, and you really have to fight it to keep the car on the straight and narrow.

Need For Speed Underground


This wheel is good for Need For Speed Underground, as smooth driving is required to avoid spinning out of control at the very high speeds involved. The gear stick is again very good for authenticity, although of course the paddles can be used if preferred. It should be noted that you should turn the strength of the force feedback up for playing this game, as in an arcade style street racing game such as this, very strong feedback makes the game that bit more exciting.

Nascar Thunder 2004


This game, as I expected, performed well with this wheel as it is a track based game. This is because it, like F1 Challenge, requires smooth, precise driving which the Momo allows so well. Again, the force feedback effects are excellent, which allow you to tell when the car is really on the edge. The effects also give a feeling of the sheer weight and power of the cars, which is essential in a Nascar game because the thrills come from the fact that it is a huge beast of a vehicle hurtling round the oval.
 

Conclusions

To summarise, here are the main pros and cons:

 

Pros

 

  • Superbly built, especially the rubber grip and realistic pedal feel.

  • The option of the sequential gear stick in addition to the well placed paddles allows for added choice and realism.

  • Pedal board does not slip easily.

  • Smooth, accurate steering is easily achievable, making the wheel suited to all track based driving games.

  • Excellent force feedback effects which really give a great feel of the road.

  • Solid clamping system.

  • Very stylish looks.

  • Easy to set up.

 

Cons

 

  • More expensive than most other wheels.

  • Buttons can be hard to reach, particularly to those small of finger and thumb.

  • Main unit is bigger than many wheels, making storage a little trickier.

  • Steering can be a little heavy for rally games where sharp, quick steering is required.

 

Compare With

Logitech Formula Force GP Wheel
Saitek R440 Force Feedback Wheel
     
Quality: 10/10
  Superb build quality, can’t fault it really.
   
Price: 7/10
  It is expensive, and as such only really worth it for hardcore simulation racers.
   
Installation: 9 /10
  Very easy to install, with clear instructions given at all stages.
   
Compatibility: 10 /10
  Works on all driving games I’ve tried, even older ones.
   
Performance : 9 /10
  Excellent force feedback effects and the choice between gear stick and paddles give excellent realism. The only downside is the slightly heavy steering.
   

 
Overall : 45/50

Excellent force feedback effects and the choice between gear stick and paddles give excellent realism. The only downside is the slightly heavy steering.

 Momo Racing Wheel

 
 Review,